By, AMMA
In the great internet battle of kitten pictures v. porn, DIY follows close and waits for an opportunity to strike back and claim dominion. It’s like the ugly cousin who’s been bullied in school for wearing braces, but your mom still made you take her all over the place even though you didn’t really like her… and you were mean to her because she was ruining your own image… and she’s been bottling up resentment ever since, plotting and waiting for that moment when she will rise up from the ashes and triumph in the internet’s Miss Popularity contest, overcoming fluffy kittens and golden showers alike, just like Fern in “Jawbreaker”.
But this realm of repurposed jeans, plastic spoons, popsicle sticks, PET bottles, pipe cleaners and wooden pallets is not just art’s little retarded brother, but a can-do promised land of talent and possibility, where we think of ourselves as emergent Miros and Picassos, Matisses and Gaudis, bursting at the seams with artistic potential, oblivious to the craft supply massacre left behind by our Frankensteinian creations and blind to the notion that we actually shouldn’t-do-it-ourselves.
It all starts innocently enough…
Every woman this side of the Ocean and North of Mexico dreams of herself as some sort of a Superwoman, successfully multitasking work, cleaning and finances, cooking and domestic transportation, child-rearing and family networking, husband satisfaction management and interior design. It takes a lot of creativity and effort to juggle all of these roles, no doubt about it, but they somehow still lack the type of validation that satisfies one’s self-expression.
Unease bubbles up as the wandering mind finds itself again and again in the craft supply department. Later, at the supermarket, the gaze moves over the 2-for-1 tuna can coupons down the conveyor belt, across the tabloids, calendars and cooking magazine, and fixates the adult mandala coloring book that strikes a chord deep within the 12-year old inside. By this point it is only a matter of time. All it takes is one DIY video to sneak into our generic heroine’s facebook feed for her to drive off to the craft store, wheels screeching, and build herself a papier-mâché cocoon from which she will reborn as:
DIYana, Queen of Carbon Footprint, Mistress of Crap Design
And that, ladies, is how you eventually poke an eye out
What Diyana isn’t taking into consideration is…
DIY is expensive
It all seemed pretty simple at first: Diyana saw an article entitled “30 ways to use spoons to make ugly decorations that you’ll throw away in a week’s time”, or something along those lines, and she decided to go for the mirror frame made of spoons. “I’ve got some spoons in the pantry that I could use!” Sounds easy enough, doesn’t it, and must surely cost less than one from the store!
“The grandkids will fight to the death over this family heirloom”, she thought.
But add anywhere between $4-14 for a box of spoons, $6-12 for the spray paint, $2 for a sheet of cardboard or $5 for a sheet of plywood, $8-40 for the round mirror, depending on your luck, $2 for picture hangers, $3 for fishing line to hang it with or $2 for a wall anchor with screws, and, if you don’t already have a glue gun, count $6+ for that and another $3 for glue sticks. Add $5 in gas and $29 in time (say you spend 4 hours on the road for supplies, cleaning the garage to make room for spray-painting, the execution itself, etc… you know it adds up, and for, say, $7.25 an hour minimum wage, your time is not cheap!). An honest calculation makes this thrifty endeavor into a $60+ investment, one that is most likely less good-looking and durable than one made with better material than goddamn plastic spoons.
But since you’ve bought a box of 100 and there’s still a few left, of course you’ll think to yourself: why not use them for a garden inspired plastic spoon flowers’ flag garland?
Your house is definitely in line for Better Homes and Gardens’ next feature with this kind of crap on your walls!
Again, you make a calculation and figure out you don’t have enough spoons left from your past endeavor, so you add another $4 for a box of spoons, $20 for enough colored card stock to make a few of these guys, $3 for assorted pom-poms, $3-5 for pom-pom ribbon… you’re starting to get the picture.
The gist is that DIY ends up costing just as much, if not more, than a factory-produced low-quality product, but is also most likely even lower quality than said product because of our amateurism, and therefore our tendency for easy-to-use, non-durable materials.
At the same time, each project requires new and different resources for it to come to life: different colored fabrics, ribbons, the glue runs out, etc., which makes it an everhungry machinery. No wonder people end up with craft rooms that have more supplies than the craft store itself!
Yeah, I got all of these that one time I made Timmy a birthday card…
According to statistics on DIY consumers, only 39% of them are partaking in this kind of practice specifically to save money, most of them “being driven to do DIY projects because they feel like they can handle the task and just because the enjoy the work.” How nice is that?
Except for the fact that…
DIY is producing a lot of garbage
This entire do-it-yourself/craft movement was in a way meant to be synonymous with recycling. You’re salvaging items that don’t have a future in your household in their current state/shape/purpose, and give them new life and use. What could be nobler than that?
Except that you’re most likely using a lot of other new materials in order to leverage the old – it’s not like you could use dried-up glue, or moldy fabrics and threads for something that you expect to survive at least until you’ve finished working on it. And for all of those supplies resources have already been spent in sourcing raw materials, chemicals, machinery, design, molds, production, storage, transportation, selling, and any other type of activity that’s part of the economic mechanism required to take something as banal as a teaspoon of oil and turn it into a plastic teaspoon that will hold a teaspoon of oil.
“Quilting” one square mile of toxic cloud at a time
TribLive.com says that “at least one project a year is crafted in about 56% of American households, according to the Craft & Hobby Association, and the industry held steady at nearly $30 billion in annual revenue through the recession, when many other retail sectors declined.”, and that “Etsy.com, an online marketplace for handmade items that said it sold $62.8 million of goods in March.” Can you even grasp how much freakin’ $0.10 cents worth of ribbon needs to be sold and used in order to get to double-digits in billions of dollars? I can’t.
So, in fact, what seemed like a super eco-friendly hobby on your part is gulping up natural resources by the ton and contributing to the same type and probably amount of pollution like any of the store-bought stupid mirror frames that you didn’t want to get because “it’s made in China”. But, at the same time, it’s not a lot better, because you end up spending those resources on garbage like this:
Wanna bet this isn’t an old stinky piece of pipe that you “saved” last time your crapper exploded?
Or this…
Who even likes Bud Light that much?!
Or this…
Is this supposed to be cute? What are you, three?
Or this…
Do people actually have 40 PET bottles lying around or just need an excuse to drink more Diet Coke?
Or this…
Timmy is totally losing his teeth if he shows up with this gem at the school cafeteria
Or this…
If I had that much room in my kitchen, I’d probably afford a table that doesn’t melt when I spill my OJ!
Or this…
Aren’t plastic flowers ugly enough already?
Or even this…
Is there honestly a manual out there on how to make garbage look like garbage?
Indeed there is. Why do I even bother?
To be fair, the fault isn’t entirely yours, because…
DIY creation are usually made by professionals
The Internet is full of DIY fail collections that tickle our self-esteem and unleash the inner Kraken of Schadenfreude – or what in layman terms is called being an asshole. It gives us hope that we shall prevail over our own craft challenges because – we think to ourselves – there’s no way we could fail that bad:
This cake needs an exorcist, not a freakin’ Pinterest page!
However, most of these projects are bound to fail from the very beginning, and not just because they used the wrong tools and supplies all the time – seriously people, how do you expect the end result to look anything like the original example when 9 out of 10 supplies don’t even resemble the ones in the instructions?!
But maybe even that isn’t entirely your fault, since understanding the properties of different types of glue, for example, comes with experience, not to mention matters of aesthetics, proportion, color-coordination and complementarity, which usually require some sort of artistic education.
That’s where a lot of the DIY tutorial creators have a significant advantage over the amateur crafter: they’re interior decorators, graphic designers who have found a niche within the DIY industry, or self-trained artists who have put enough energy and creativity into this hobby and turned it into a lucrative business. The gist is they actually have a knack for it!
It takes hundreds of hours, if not more, of practice to have the kind of control over line drawing that most of these videos show, to handle scissors confidently and turn the simplest of movements into a dance. It probably takes a few good tries at the same project, with different materials to figure out which works best, and most certainly some fails of their own before the right combination is found. It also takes an eye for design that most of us, unfortunately, do not have and most likely don’t have the time to develop, since we’re not planning on building career, but a stupid plastic spoon mirror, or some Bud Light candles, or even a melted crayon painting:
Could it really be that people are this incapable? Of course they are.
Letting go of Peter Pan
The sad truth is that technology and mass-production have robbed us of the simple pleasure of day-to-day tasks where creativity used to be involved in every domestic activity, from sewing a table cloth or a traditional blouse, to sculpting an ax handle out of a tree trunk. What used to be a daily occurrence is now a luxury, and as our artistic contributions to the surrounding world have diminished, so have our skills lost practice, and along with it the joy they used to bring. Have we completely run out of opportunities to express ourselves and satisfy the creative need?
The world is still our oyster, and as art evolves into more of a popular movement than ever, with free software and online courses designed to help us learn and understand more, to grow and find new ways of expressions, DIY stays behind as an unfortunate and polluting hobby. It is a modern-day embodiment of the “Peter Pan Syndrome”, where we, as grown-ups stuck at or repeatedly regressing towards an adolescent emotional level, refuse to put the toys away and try to steal another moment of pure fun and joy. Continuous development is a mantra hummed by HRs like Buddhist monks hum their prayers, and creative thinking is encouraged in any form and shape, as it only should.
But are arts and crafts, a benchmark in the normal development in children, something that we still need to reduce our creative energies to, or are they just a sign of greediness and resource irresponsibility, cementing this idea that we are still just adolescents? And if we claim it isn’t so, are we willing to give the plastic spoon mirror above 5 tries until the spoons are perfectly aligned, to try 4 different types of spray paint to see which brand works better for the kind of plastic used in that spoon, to file each section of decapitated spoon into a flawless edge, until our hideous creation starts looking like a finished product?
And furthermore, are we OK with the added costs, time consumption and subsequent garbage that come with our own experiments?
My prerogative is simple: let go of Peter Pan and allow the grown-up to take over; recycle and upcycle instead of hoarding supplies; put resources (material, time and energy) into things that really matter, and, for crying out loud, if you can’t even paint your nails after you’ve wrapped your leg in Cling wrap and masking tape, just give up on DIY completely:
The best way to do a pedicure is to start from the armpits